Your best employee just asked for a meeting.
You can tell from the message that it’s not about a project. Something is wrong.
What you do in the next 72 hours will either keep them or lose them. Most founders handle this badly — not because they don’t care, but because they don’t have a framework for it.
The First Conversation
When they tell you they’re thinking about leaving — or have already received another offer — resist the instinct to immediately counter.
The first conversation has one job: understand what’s actually going on.
Ask these questions in this order:
“What’s prompting this now?” Not “what did they offer you” — what’s driving the decision. The offer is usually not the root cause. Something at your company made them open to listening to another offer in the first place.
“What would need to be different here for you to want to stay?” This is the question most founders never ask. It gives the person permission to tell you what’s wrong, and it tells you whether the real problem is solvable.
“Is this about this role specifically, or something broader?” Sometimes the decision is about the company. Sometimes it’s about life — a partner’s job, a desire to move, a need for a different kind of challenge. Knowing which it is changes everything.
Use this prompt to prepare:
“My best employee has told me they’re considering leaving. I want to have a retention conversation that’s honest and not desperate. Help me: (1) Open the conversation in a way that invites honesty rather than shutting it down, (2) Ask the questions that reveal the real reason they’re considering leaving, (3) Listen for the things between the lines — what they’re not saying directly, (4) Know when I’ve heard something that means they’ve already made up their mind versus something that means the door is still open.”
What’s Usually Actually Going On
In my experience the stated reason for leaving is almost never the real reason.
“I got a better offer” usually means: I didn’t feel valued here, and a better offer confirmed that someone else sees what I’m worth.
“I want a new challenge” usually means: I’ve stopped growing in this role and I don’t see a path forward.
“It’s a better opportunity” usually means: something at this company — a manager, a direction, a culture problem — was making me unhappy enough to look.
The better offer, the new challenge, the new opportunity — those are doors. Something at your company opened the door.
Your job in the first conversation is to find out what opened the door.
When to Counter — and When Not To
Counter if: the reason they’re leaving is genuinely fixable, you can address the root problem not just the symptom, and they have explicitly said they would stay if X changed.
Don’t counter if: the real reason is something you can’t fix — a fundamental mismatch in career direction, a desire to move cities, a need for a change of environment. Countering in those situations buys you 3-6 months before they leave anyway, and it’s usually worse for both of you.
Don’t match an offer if: money isn’t the real issue. A salary increase doesn’t fix a broken manager relationship or a lack of growth path. You’ll pay more for someone who’s still looking.
If They Decide to Leave
Handle it well. Every founder has people leave — what separates good founders from bad ones is how they handle it.
Give them a proper send-off. Do a thorough knowledge transfer. Don’t punish them by removing access early or making the last few weeks awkward. The startup world is small. How you treat people when they leave is how you build or destroy your reputation as a place people want to work.
The exit interview is the most valuable research you’ll do this month. Ask: what’s the one thing we could have done differently that might have kept you? What should we know about how this company feels from inside that we might not see from the top? What advice would you give the person taking your role?
Use this prompt to prepare:
“A valued employee is leaving my company. I want to conduct an exit interview that produces genuinely useful information — not a polite conversation that tells me nothing. Give me: (1) The 5 questions most likely to surface honest feedback about what we could do better, (2) How to create the psychological safety that makes honest answers possible when I’m the one asking, (3) What to do with the information after the interview to make sure it actually changes something.”
Get the Full People Ops Prompt Library
50 prompts for retention conversations, performance management, hiring, and more — free download.